Few boats capture the spirit of practical boating like the Boston Whaler 170 Montauk. Compact yet capable, this classic center console has earned its reputation as a versatile runabout that combines legendary Whaler toughness with modern updates. For boaters who want something easy to handle, trailer, and store—but still big enough for fishing, cruising, or family fun—the 170 Montauk delivers a package that’s straightforward yet highly rewarding.

This model is often described as the perfect entry point into the Boston Whaler lineup. It’s not oversized, intimidating, or overcomplicated. Instead, it’s approachable without feeling basic. With thoughtful seating layouts, smart use of space, and reliable Mercury power, it provides confidence on the water for seasoned captains and newcomers alike. In this review, we’ll take a close look at what makes the 170 Montauk such a popular choice, how it compares to competitors, and whether it might be the right boat for you.

Everyday Functionality and Purpose

The 170 Montauk is designed to be the ultimate multipurpose center console. It doesn’t try to be flashy or excessive—instead, it focuses on practicality, ease of use, and all-around versatility. Its shallow draft makes it perfect for exploring bays, rivers, and lakes, while its solid hull ensures it can handle choppier coastal conditions with confidence.

Because of its compact size, the boat is equally at home being trailered to new destinations or kept at a marina slip for quick outings. Boston Whaler designed this model with a “just-right” balance of portability and capability, making it an excellent boat for everything from casting lines on an inland lake to cruising to your favorite waterfront restaurant.

Who Will Enjoy the 170 Montauk Most?

The 170 Montauk is well-suited to boaters who want simplicity with reliability. Families will appreciate the safe, open layout that makes moving around the boat easy, while anglers benefit from uncluttered deck space that’s ideal for casting and fighting fish. It’s also a fantastic boat for first-time owners who want something easy to maintain yet built with Boston Whaler’s famously unsinkable construction.

Seasoned boaters may use it as a convenient second vessel—a boat that’s quick to launch, efficient to run, and versatile enough for a variety of quick outings. Young boaters and smaller crews, meanwhile, will find the 170 Montauk approachable and unintimidating while still delivering the premium quality the brand is known for.

How Does the 170 Montauk Compare to Other Offshore Boats?

When stacked against other compact center consoles, the 170 Montauk holds its own thanks to Boston Whaler’s unsinkable hull design and reputation for durability. While boats in this size class from competitors like Key West or Scout offer similar layouts, the Montauk sets itself apart with ruggedness and a resale value that’s consistently strong.

It isn’t a long-range offshore boat, but compared to other sub-20-foot options, it feels more capable and secure in rougher water. Buyers often note that the Montauk feels like a “bigger boat in a smaller package,” which is why many prefer it over entry-level alternatives.

Technical Breakdown of Specs and Layout

Here’s a look at the core specifications of the Boston Whaler 170 Montauk:

• Type: Center Console
• Length Overall (LOA): 17 feet 4 inches
• Beam: 7 feet 3 inches
• Draft: 12 inches (approx.)
• Fuel Capacity: 25 gallons
• Engines: Standard Mercury 90 FourStroke (optional 115 HP upgrade)
• Top Speed: Around 40–44 mph (with 115 HP)
• Cruise Speed: 25–30 mph
• Hull Design: Modified V-hull with foam-filled construction
• Seating Layout: Forward bow cushion with backrest, reversible pilot seat, aft jump seats, and open casting space

The seating configuration is cleverly designed to maximize space in a compact footprint. A reversible pilot seat doubles as a leaning post, while forward seating adds comfort for passengers or serves as casting space for anglers. Storage compartments are integrated throughout, providing a place for gear without cluttering the deck.

On-Water Experience and Performance

On the water, the 170 Montauk offers a ride that feels stable and reassuring. With its unsinkable hull and modest draft, it handles well in both calm lakes and light coastal chop. While it won’t match the offshore muscle of larger Whalers, it provides confidence for the type of trips most owners will take—whether fishing, tubing, or cruising.

Performance with the standard 90 HP engine is efficient and smooth, while the optional 115 HP adds a bit more punch for those who prioritize speed. Handling is light and predictable, making the boat easy for newer captains to learn on. Its small size also means maneuvering around docks or trailering is far less stressful compared to larger center consoles.

Safety Features and Considerations

Boston Whaler is known for building unsinkable boats, and the 170 Montauk proudly carries that legacy. Its foam-filled hull construction ensures buoyancy even if the boat is swamped, which is a huge reassurance for families and beginners. High gunwales and an uncluttered deck also add to its safety profile, reducing trip hazards and giving passengers a secure feel onboard.

The boat does, however, have limitations. Its size means it’s not designed for extended offshore runs in heavy seas, and storage for fuel and gear is limited compared to larger models. Owners need to keep their outings within the capabilities of the boat, but within those parameters, safety is one of its strongest assets.

Things to Keep in Mind

While the 170 Montauk shines in many areas, potential buyers should weigh a few realities. First, space onboard is functional but limited—larger crews may feel cramped on longer outings. Second, although the boat is versatile, it lacks the full luxury finishes of bigger Whalers, focusing instead on durability and simplicity.

Finally, while fuel economy is excellent, the smaller tank capacity requires more frequent refueling on long days of cruising. These are not flaws, but trade-offs that come naturally with a compact center console.

Features and Benefits

The features of the 170 Montauk are thoughtfully selected to provide comfort without overcomplication. Owners will enjoy:

• A reversible pilot seat with multiple positions.
• Optional fishing packages that include rod holders, tackle storage, and a livewell.
• Bow cushion and backrest that convert the front area into a lounge.
• Jump seats at the stern for added passenger comfort.
• Stainless hardware and durable finishes built to last.

These features make the 170 Montauk flexible enough for anglers, families, and recreational boaters alike. Boston Whaler also offers customization through optional packages, ensuring owners can tailor the boat to their preferred style of use.

What Owners Are Saying

Owners of the 170 Montauk frequently highlight its ease of ownership and durability. Many first-time boaters note how approachable the boat feels, while longtime owners often praise the quality that has kept their Montauks reliable for years. Common feedback also points to excellent resale value, with pre-owned Montauks commanding strong prices thanks to the brand’s reputation.

Compared to competitors, owners often describe the Montauk as “the safe choice”—not because it’s plain, but because it’s a model you can rely on to do everything it promises.

Ownership Costs and Value

Operating costs on the 170 Montauk are refreshingly reasonable. Its small fuel tank and efficient Mercury engine mean a day of cruising rarely dents the wallet. Maintenance costs are also modest compared to larger boats, though Whaler parts and accessories typically carry a premium.

Insurance is accessible due to its smaller size, and storage is easy—many owners keep their 170 Montauk at home on a trailer, avoiding marina fees altogether. When combined with strong resale value, ownership is among the most cost-effective in the Boston Whaler lineup.

Final Thoughts

The Boston Whaler 170 Montauk remains one of the most approachable, versatile, and enduring center consoles on the market. It may not be the biggest or the fastest, but it’s a boat that prioritizes confidence, ease of use, and durability in a way that few competitors match. For families, first-time buyers, or boaters who just want something simple yet capable, it’s hard to go wrong with this classic model.

If you want a boat that delivers legendary Boston Whaler toughness in a compact, affordable, and easy-to-own package, the 170 Montauk is worth serious consideration.

FAQ

What is the maximum horsepower for the 170 Montauk?
The boat comes standard with a Mercury 90 HP engine, but you can upgrade to a 115 HP engine for higher top-end speed and better performance with heavier loads.

Can the 170 Montauk handle saltwater use?
Yes, absolutely. It’s designed with marine-grade finishes and hardware suitable for saltwater, though like any boat, regular rinsing and maintenance are recommended.

Is the 170 Montauk trailerable?
Yes. At just over 17 feet, the Montauk is easily trailered with a mid-sized vehicle, making it convenient to store at home or transport to new waters.

How many people can the 170 Montauk carry?
The maximum capacity is seven passengers, though comfort is best with four to five people onboard for longer outings.

What are some popular upgrades for this model?
Many owners opt for the fishing package with a livewell, rod holders, and additional storage, as well as the upgraded 115 HP engine for enhanced performance.

Fly Yachts provides a full range of services, starting with a large inventory of yachts for sale and information about luxury yachts, super yachts, and center consoles, all easily found from their homepage. To learn about their company history, team, and expert knowledge, check their About Us page, and if you want a custom yacht built, visit Build a Yacht. They feature travel options to various charter destinations around the world and list many yachts charter choices for private bookings. If you want to sell your vessel, the Sell Your Yacht page explains their process and support. For private aviation, they offer a selection of aircraft for sale. You can stay up to date on industry updates and company activities on the Gulfstream News page, and find yachting tips or advice in their Compass Articles. For any help or to get in touch, you can use the Contact page.